Winner-take-all electoral college system is unconstitutional, say suits led by Boies
ABA Journal Feb 22, 2018
A coalition of prominent law firms and professors has filed four federal lawsuits claiming the winner-take-all system of electoral college voting distorts presidential campaigns and violates the U.S. Constitution.
The Constitution provides that “electors” choose the president and vice president, while states determine how electors are selected, the suits explain. Forty-eight states and Washington, D.C., have winner-take-all systems for choosing electors in which the political party of the leading candidate selects every elector. The system magnifies votes by those who chose the winner and discards the votes of others.
In Texas, for example, Donald Trump received 52.2 percent of the vote in 2016, yet he received every single electoral vote in the state, according to the suit filed there. Hillary Clinton received 43.2 percent of the Texas vote, but zero electoral votes. The suits are available here.
San Antonio Express-News: San Antonio judge weighs legality of Electoral College process in choosing a president
San Antonio judge weighs legality of Electoral College process in choosing a president San Antonio Express-News Feb 13 2019 Lawyers for the state on Wednesday asked a federal judge to throw out a lawsuit challenging Texas’ Electoral College process as plaintiffs dug...read more
Judge rejects challenge to Massachusetts’ winner-take-all election system Associated Press Dec 7, 2018 BOSTON (AP) — A federal judge on Friday dismissed a lawsuit challenging the winner-take-all system Massachusetts uses to assign its Electoral College presidential...read more
The Electoral College Dilemma BC Law Nov 2, 2018 Calling the Electoral College one of the “least understood disasters at the core of our Constitution,” Harvard Professor Lawrence Lessig (above) launched a Rappaport Center for Law and Public Policy discussion convened...read more
Minority Rule: Why Our Undemocratic Republic Must Give Way To Something Else WGBH Oct 11, 2018 If something can’t go on forever, then it won’t. And so it is with the current state of our democracy, which awards disproportionate power to an ever-shrinking slice of the...read more
Democracy Café: Why Joaquin Gonzalez has joined the all-out effort to overhaul the Electoral College
Why Joaquin Gonzalez has joined the all-out effort to overhaul the Electoral College Democracy Café Sep 14, 2018 When Joaquin Gonzalez heard about the effort of Harvard Law Professor Lawrence Lessig and other compatriots to challenge and prospectively overhaul the...read more
Want a better president, better elections? States need to stop winner take all Questions: How can we increase the chances we get the president the majority of us vote for in 2020—unlike who we got in 2016 and 2000? And how can we also benefit from fairer election...read more
Galvin, Zakim Trade Verbal Punches Commonwealth Magazine Aug 15, 2018 There was no love lost between Secretary of State William Galvin and Boston City Councilor Josh Zakim who squared off in a tense half-hour television debate on Tuesday evening, trading verbal...read more
High-Profile Attorneys Push for Change to Electoral College System NBC Boston Aug 10 A group of attorneys is pushing for a change to the electoral college system. The group includes former Massachusetts Gov. William Weld, David Boies and Harvard law professor Lawrence...read more
The Blaze: Group sues four states to challenge winner-take-all system for Electoral College selection
Group sues four states to challenge winner-take-all system for Electoral College selection The Blaze Aug 13, 2018 A group is suing four U.S. states, claiming that the winner-take-all system for Electoral College selection disenfranchises voters and encourages...read more