The Challenge To “Winner-Take-All” Launched
Lawrence Lessig @ IVN.US Feb 23, 2018
Beginning today, in four states across the country, lawsuits will be filed to challenge the way presidential electors are selected in America. The plaintiffs in these suits charge that the “winner-take-all” system—the system by which the candidate who wins the popular vote in a state gets all of the electoral college votes in that state—violates both the 14th Amendment’s principle of “one person, one vote,” and the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment.
A Republican in California, no less than a Democrat in Texas, voting for the President of the United States should have her vote for President counted equally, regardless of whether she happens to vote with the majority in her state. Yet under the system as it is now, their votes are counted unequally. If they vote with the majority, their vote matters. If they vote with the minority, their vote counts for zero.
That makes no sense in any democracy; it makes no sense in ours, at least against the background of the principles embedded within our Constitution. That point we believe these cases will prove.
Jason Harrow @ USA Today: Donald Trump is no electoral phenom. He’s more like Michael Dukakis than Ronald Reagan.
Donald Trump is no electoral phenom. He's more like Michael Dukakis than Ronald Reagan. Jason Harrow @ USA Today November 6, 2018 Civil rights activists are challenging the legality of four states’ winner-take-all method of allocating U.S. presidential electoral...read more
Electoral College Confusions Lessig @ The Hill October 31, 2018 Civil rights activists are challenging the legality of four states’ winner-take-all method of allocating U.S. presidential electoral college votes, claiming the practice magnifies some votes at the...read more
Courts to Hear Legal Challenge to Electoral College Jason Harrow @ Independent Voter Network September 18, 2018 What can be done to improve the way we elect our president? The current system, where nearly every state gives all of its electoral votes to whatever...read more
Here’s a Good Enough Solution to the Way We Elect US Presidents Jason Harrow @ The Hill August 22, 2018 Here is a common conundrum. You’ve been searching for flights to Florida for that dream family vacation. You want to go in about three months, and you find what you...read more
Texas’ Winner-Take-All Elections Mean Unfair Results Jason Harrow @ Houston Chronicle May 29, 2018 President Trump said something recently in an interview that most Americans should be able to agree on: We should change the way we elect the president. He told Fox &...read more
Adam Eichen @ Medium: The Electoral College Reform Movement Made Great Strides This Month, But Is It Enough?
The Electoral College Reform Movement Made Great Strides This Month, But Is It Enough? Adam Eichen @ Medium May 29, 2018 Last week, with little fanfare, Connecticut governor Dannel Malloy signed a bill that officially adds his state to the National Popular Vote...read more
Jason Harrow @ USA Today: The winner-take-all presidential system is unconstitutional. We’re taking it to court.
The winner-take-all presidential system is unconstitutional. We're taking it to court. Jason Harrow @ USA Today Mar 8, 2018 There's no legal justification for states’ use of winner-take-all. It’s an unconstitutional way to pick the electors who cast votes for...read more
The Challenge to "Winner-take-all" Launched Lawrence Lessig @ Medium Feb 21, 2018 Beginning today, in four states across the country, lawsuits will be filed to challenge the way presidential electors are selected in America. The plaintiffs in these suits charge that...read more
Important Update on the Equal Votes project Equal Citizens @ Medium Feb 5, 2018 Stay tuned, because we’re about to make a big announcement about our case(s). But meanwhile, we wanted to address an important concern that many have written about. We believe — as anyone...read more